Tuesday, February 2, 2016

WEEKLY COMMENTARY: An E'port Tutor Talks About Creating A Relationship With A Disbelieving Stranger

It was 7:00 o'clock on a Tuesday evening several years ago, and I had just joined the Elizabethport Tutorial Program at Central Presbyterian Church.  I had been accepted as a tutor, along with about 60 other local high school students.

Suddenly, there was a flurry of activity and noise --- the big yellow school bus from Elizabethport had arrived carrying about 40 expectant grade school students from the inner city of Elizabeth, New Jersey.

I sat alone at a table in the church auditorium, waiting for the girl I had never met.  Spread out on the table in front of me were some materials I thought might interest my new student. Shortly, one of the program's adult supervisors came to my table with a young girl student. Her name was Latoya.  She was twelve years old and reluctantly approached the table, eyeing me with distrust and suspicion.

"Welcome!" I said in a friendly manner, trying to hide my nervousness.  "My name is Pattie." Then I introduced myself, describing my high school, my family and some of my extra-curricular activities.  Latoya sat indifferently and disinterested, staring at the tiled floor.  I questioned her, but that did not evoke responses.

I asked her if she liked to read, but Latoya looked at me like I was some kind of nerd.  I had brought a simply-written paragraph to test her reading level, so I asked her to read it to me.  In a monotone, barely an audible whisper, she rattled off the various random words on the page that she recognized, slurring them together as if she was reading them in consecutive sentences.  My palms began to sweat, and my heart began to pound.  Do I dare correct her? Maybe I should never have signed up for this!

Then Latoya asked if she could color some pictures.  Relieved, I found a connect-the-dots picture and a few markers and let her get to work.  After what seemed like hours, the bus driver called for the children to line up.  Grabbing her coat and bag, Latoya got out of her chair and took a few steps to the door.  With a look back over her shoulder, she spoke to me . . .
                  "You gonna be here next week?"
"NO!"  My inner voice wanted to say.  What a disaster!  How can I ever come back!  No way!  Forcing a smile, I looked at her, "Of course! I'll see you next week!"

She turned and disappeared in the hoard of children pushing and shoving their way out the door.  I let out a small cry of anguish, utterly exhausted.

That was my first session with Latoya, and the next few were not much better.  My difficulty in developing a positive rapport with my insolent student continued.  Latoya rejected my friendly overtures and scoffed when I corrected her grammatical, mathematical, or reading mistakes.  Although, she never missed a Tuesday night session, Latoya frequently refused to do any work at all.  For weeks, she would come to the table where I sat, and we would color.  Silently.  Or she would go wandering round the room, visiting her friends, or taking unnecessary trips to the bathroom. I found myself frequently searching for her, completely discouraged, and feeling that I was merely Latoya's entertainment.  Having started the program with the noblest intentions of "making a difference," I was disheartened as I became certain that Latoya didn't even know my first name.

However, I refused to be beaten,  I had an idea.  I brought three very loved books off my own bookshelf.  They were Shel Silverstein's, The Giving Tree,  A Light in the Attic, and Where the Sidewalk Ends

Tuesday night arrived and I was armed and ready.  Latoya walked over, and immediately asked to use the bathroom.  I consented, but insisted on accompanying her.  By the way she looked at me, I could tell she knew something was up.

When we returned to the table, I sat her down and explained that these were books my dad had read to me when I was younger, that they were great, and that I was going to read them to her.  She agreed, as long as she could pick which one.  She picked The Giving Tree, presumably because it was the shortest, so we would be done sooner.

I opened the book, and began to read.  Latoya initially mocked the story line, called the tree "stupid" for giving the little boy everything, and laughed at me for actually liking the book. But gradually, she began to search the simply drawn, progressive pictures, and enjoy watching the little boy grow older and older until he was a wrinkled little man.  I watched her face as I read;  I saw her defensive, sharp eyes open and laugh.

I explained that Where the Sidewalk Ends and A Light in the Attic, were collections of poems.  We discussed what poems were, and I asked her to read some.  She and I both laughed at the pictures.  Then she turned to my favorite, "The Twistable Turntable Man," and I insisted on reading it to her, just as my dad had read it to me.  Taking a deep breath, I delighted her in reading the quick rhyming poem at record speed.  "Again!" she said, "Pattie, read it again." 

Shocked at hearing her say my name, I did as I was told me.  And she laughed.  And then Latoya tried to read it, and stumbled over the words so badly they began to sound like gibberish, and she laughed at herself.  She called over her friends and commanded me to read it to them.  We all laughed and she asked me to read it over and over and over.  At the end of the night, Latoya characteristically grabbed her coat and bag, and headed for the door.  Suddenly, however, she ran back, gave me a hug, and then disappeared.

I realized that although Latoya was rowdy and difficult, she was not the demon I had thought her to be, but merely a hardened little girl who had led a tough life.  She had learned not to trust anyone.  I discovered that she did appreciate me, not for the math work we did, or for my grammatical corrections, but for being there every Tuesday night.  I suddenly realized that just by reaching out every week, I was "making a difference," and it was an incredible feeling.

I have decided that this type of service, sharing what I have learned or experienced with less fortunate individuals, while sometimes difficult and trying, is essentially important to living a healthy, fulfilled life.  This endeavor will become a major part of my life, no matter what profession I decide to pursue.

          And the best is yet to come. . . .

The next week, Latoya returned and leaned over to me and said, "You know that book? The tree one?  They have it in the library at my school.

My heart soared.  On the subject of libraries, Latoya had told me that they were for "nerds" and "wimps," and were "stupid."  Yet she had gone to the library and had taken the book home to read to her little brother.  I sat there, at our table, swimming in pride and accomplishment, and beaming at Latoya.

She however, remaining in character, gave me a look as if I were out of my mind, and asked to go to the bathroom.
___________________________________________________________________________

Our thanks to Sarah Coyle, a former E'port Tutor, who shared her emotions for this story.
___________________________________________________________________________

These words are brought to you by the CPC Adult Spiritual Development Team, hoping to encourage your spiritual growth this winter.
___________________________________________________________________________


No comments:

Post a Comment