Monday, June 19, 2017

WEEKLY COMMENTARY: Misunderstandings Between Christians and Muslims



On Saturday, June 17th, our Mission Team hosted, at Central Church, two Presbyterian missionaries who have lived and worked in a war zone for several years.

You have heard much about the on-going fight to recover Mosul, Iraq's second largest city.  One hour's drive north is Dohuk in the Iraqi province of Kurdistan. It is in Dohuk where these missionaries live and work.

While they are not personally under fire, they are focused on some of the evils of long-term war conditions.  They work with displaced persons from Mosul, they help teach children whose schools were destroyed, sometimes they organize medical assistance for people in need, and importantly they show the Christian faith in action.

Our meeting with them was more than just a mission-grant discussion!  While the Mission Team did vote to make a grant to them, the longer-term benefit of this meeting was to explore some ways we can narrow the gap between Islam and Christianity.  This important objective is a goal at Central Church ---- building bridges of understanding between Christians and followers of Islam. This occasion was a nice opportunity to hear first-hand some ideas from Presbyterian folks living in a Muslim culture.

While much of interest was imparted in the verbal discussion, our visitors also offered us some valuable and authentic written materials, as well.  Some of the following is drawn from those materials.

What Muslims Believe:

1.) Muslims understand religion as a whole and integrated way of life.  They see it as the total code of their social and personal values, not limited to just spiritual and God-related beliefs. Secular and Christian-influenced cultures can confuse and even anger Muslims who see things completely through their holistic world view.  For example, they often mistakenly view "Hollywood and sexuality" as part of the Christian faith.

2.) In the practice of Islam, brotherhood and consensus is emphasized, and individualism is avoided.  It is the duty of the "community of the faithful" to enforce the moral and social codes of belief and behavior.  This may explain how a lone Muslim, outside a community support structure, does not feel very guilty when breaking the code.  However, bringing shame on his family or community would be seen as a great sin.

3.) Avoiding shame and protecting honor are the primary motivations of most Muslims. Because shame and honor are community-related, they are to be contrasted with Western emphasis on individualism with its possibly of a strong sense of personal guilt for wrong-doing.

4.) Radical Muslims, often called "Jihadists," use this sense of community honor and shame to recruit and motivate their followers.

5.) Perhaps the greatest conflict  between Western values and Muslim beliefs, is in regard to the role of women.  Some Muslims say that adopting Western values regarding the role and behavior of women would be more feared than the problems they address.  However, many Muslim women say they prefer their family-based life style, as opposed to lonely singleness, sexual exploitation, and the desire for money that makes home and family unimportant.

6.) Muslims are often quite gender-sensitive, interacting man to man, woman to woman.  They try hard to avoid any compromising situation, even just to protect from a possible rumor.  An Arab proverb says, "A man and woman alone together are three with the devil."

7.) Muslims are taught to practice modesty, even among Westernized Muslims. For women, this often takes the form of loose-fitting out-of-home clothing which hides their facial and other female features. For women this is very important because family honor is tied to their behavior and reputation.

What Christians Believe:

1.) Followers of Jesus believe that they are to impact culture for Christ by going into all parts of the world to peacefully bring the message of Jesus to the people who live there.  It wasn't always so, as in earlier centuries Christian Crusades in the Middle East violently attempted to convert or kill Muslims and other non-Christians.  Today, some radical Muslims attempt to use the same method of religious conversion on Christians.

2.) In the West, a division exists between culture and religion.  Religion is separated from government, and some people object to any influence of religion on state institutions and symbols.

3.) Followers of Jesus do influence Western culture and institutions, but less so than Muslims do, because Western culture affirms individualism, and community/family responsibility is less compelling.  Some Muslims say that tolerance of sin and non-Biblical practices continue in Western society to dilute the true Christian message.  Generally, they say, Western culture does not have a widespread sense of the "community of the faithful," compared to the Muslims.

4.) The easy commercialism and acceptance of popular trends in the West play to the fear of Muslims of being dominated and corrupted morally by "Christianity."

This interesting meeting left many of us considering how extensively the culture we happen to live in shapes the practice of our relationship with God.  However, it was reassuring to find we have many ideas and practices in common with our Muslim brothers and sisters.
_______________________________________________________________________________

These thoughts are brought to you by CPC's Adult Spiritual Development Team, hoping to encourage you to pursue some personal spiritual growth this summer at CPC.
______________________________________________________________________________ 


No comments:

Post a Comment